A bit of greater than a yr in the past, the way forward for New York Group Bancorp was unsettled, at finest.
The Lengthy Island-based firm, which dominated the New York Metropolis multifamily lending area for many years, was ill-equipped to take care of the fast progress that stemmed from two hefty acquisitions — Flagstar Bancorp in late 2022 and remnants of Signature Financial institution in early 2023.
Now the financial institution was making an attempt to claw its manner out of a harmful state of affairs: Its industrial actual property portfolio was harassed, its inventory worth had plummeted and clients had been yanking out deposits.
New York Group swapped out management, disclosed materials weaknesses in its inside controls and rushed to fill lately vacated roles, together with chief danger officer. Analysts and rankings companies downgraded the corporate, saying reserve-building to guard towards losses would crimp its earnings.
As questions swirled about whether or not New York Group would survive, Joseph Otting was on the lookout for a possibility to get again into the banking enterprise. The 67-year-old Otting — a one-time CEO of California-based OneWest Financial institution who later turned the Comptroller of the Forex through the first Trump administration — wasn’t essentially on the lookout for a financial institution CEO job.
However that is what he received when he, together with former Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin and different traders, determined to inject $1.05 billion of capital into the beleaguered New York firm, stabilizing it towards additional deterioration and allaying a number of the market’s fears about its survivability.
Otting, who can also be the corporate’s chairman, moved shortly to get his fingers across the issues, tackling capital points and potential credit score losses whereas promoting off noncore companies and changing a lot of the legacy New York Group board and administration group together with his former colleagues and associates. The brand new group renamed the corporate Flagstar Monetary final fall.
“After we received right here, the questions at the moment had been, ‘Hey, does the financial institution have sufficient liquidity? Does it have sufficient capital? And the way unhealthy can the credit score losses be?'” Otting advised American Banker this week in certainly one of his first formal media interviews since changing into CEO a yr in the past.
“And so for the primary six to 9 months, we undertook a course of to take a look at what we would like the financial institution to be [and] what [could] we contemplate divesting, in order that we might strengthen and bolster the capital and liquidity of the corporate and slender the main target … to being a traditional regional financial institution.”
Twelve months into Otting’s tenure, Flagstar remains to be firmly in reconstruction mode, however analysts say its transformation right into a traditional regional financial institution is effectively underway. It is charging after commercial-and-industrial mortgage progress, aided by plans to rent 100 industrial bankers this yr. It is increase its capital — its widespread fairness Tier 1 ratio for the fourth quarter of 2024 was 11.86% — and it is persevering with to chop prices, aiming to trim $600 million in whole.
Following quarterly losses in every of the 4 quarters of 2024, firm executives are forecasting a return to profitability within the fourth quarter of this yr. That may very well be a tall order. Rising rates of interest, an financial slowdown and fewer commercial-and-industrial progress than anticipated might get in the way in which.
Flagstar should additionally preserve decreasing its industrial actual property publicity, mentioned Ebrahim Poonawala, an analyst at Financial institution of America Securities. On the finish of December, multifamily loans made up 47% of the corporate’s whole mortgage e book, the best of its peer group, the financial institution disclosed in January.
“I do not need to underestimate the execution danger,” Poonawala mentioned. “Operating a financial institution is troublesome, interval. Operating a financial institution that is primarily a de novo financial institution utilizing the New York Group and Flagstar legacy is doubly troublesome. However what helps is: The administration group has a playbook.”
‘Cruising proper alongside’
New York Group spent 5 many years carving a distinct segment for itself because the dominant lender of multifamily loans within the New York Metropolis market. By late 2018, 75% of its mortgage e book was multifamily, and greater than 77% of these loans had been made within the metro New York Metropolis area.
The business-model rationale was easy: The portfolio was largely low-risk loans on non-luxury, rent-controlled buildings, and losses on such properties had been extraordinarily low.
In the meantime, different industrial actual property loans, together with workplace constructing credit, made up 17% of all loans. Industrial-and-industrial loans had been only a sliver of the pie at round 6%.
The corporate made makes an attempt to cut back its reliance on multifamily lending and shift its funding combine from higher-cost wholesale borrowing and certificates of deposits to lower-cost deposits. Its 2022 acquisition of mortgage heavy-hitter Flagstar was an try to combine up the portfolio whereas additionally drawing in sorely wanted lower-cost deposits.
4 months after closing the acquisition of Troy, Michigan-based Flagstar, New York Group acquired a lot of the failed Signature Financial institution in New York Metropolis. The 2 offers pushed the mixed group above the $100 billion-asset threshold “prior to anticipated,” then-CEO Thomas Cangemi mentioned on the time. The financial institution was out of the blue in a brand new realm, the place the expectations for danger governance and compliance had been increased.
By the point Otting arrived in 2024, the corporate was in bother. It had reported an surprising and sizable loss for the fourth quarter of 2023, disclosed stress in multifamily and workplace loans resulting from higher-for-longer rates of interest, bolstered its reserves for unhealthy loans and reduce its dividend.
“This occurred out of left area,” recalled Chris Marinac, an analyst at Janney Montgomery Scott who’s coated the financial institution for years. “This was an organization that was cruising alongside. This was a ‘made’ financial institution, and so they had been seen like this as a result of that they had been blessed by the [Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.] to purchase Signature Financial institution. However then they really needed to run that financial institution.”
“They needed to acknowledge Signature’s danger and their very own danger, and so they had been too sluggish to reply.”
‘A very good street map’
Otting and his group did not waste a minute. They started working assessing the financial institution’s danger administration and inside controls construction. They started a monthslong assessment of your complete mortgage e book. They engaged with regulators, overhauled the board to incorporate administrators with bigger-bank expertise and started hiring new leaders to run the completely different enterprise segments.
A lot of these people are folks whom Otting has labored with beforehand. They’ve achieved stints at U.S. Bancorp, the place Otting was vice chair; at OneWest, the place he and Mnuchin turned across the failed IndyMac Financial institution and later bought it to CIT Group for a big revenue; and on the Workplace of the Comptroller of the Forex, the place Otting was the highest regulator from 2017 to 2020.
Flagstar additionally bought sure noncore property, together with $5 billion of mortgage warehouse loans, which had been acquired in Might by JPMorgan Chase, and its residential mortgage servicing unit, which was purchased final fall by Mr. Cooper. These gross sales boosted capital ranges.
By Might, the corporate was able to share its three-year targets, a transfer that Otting described to American Banker as “ballsy.” The targets embrace attaining an effectivity ratio of 55% to 60%, a standard fairness Tier 1 ratio of 11% to 12% and a return on common tangible widespread fairness in the identical 11% to 12% vary. The forecast additionally contains targets for internet curiosity revenue and internet curiosity margin, charge revenue, noninterest bills and provisions for mortgage losses.
“We actually thought it was necessary to information folks … about the place precisely we wished to take this financial institution,” Otting mentioned. It is “a extremely good street map whenever you mix it with our strategic plan.”
In some methods, the work has been much like what Otting and Mnuchin did at IndyMac and OneWest. Like New York Group, IndyMac was closely concentrated in a single section, mortgages. So Otting needed to construct a industrial financial institution and diversify the steadiness sheet, he mentioned.
That have is essential for Flagstar’s success, Marinac mentioned.
“What occurred with OneWest could be very instructive to what’s taking place right here,” Marinac mentioned. “It contains not simply turning round an issue financial institution, however making a enterprise and increasing it after which doing one thing with it. … That is about making an attempt to develop [while] fixing credit score points.”
‘Can this financial institution … change into worthwhile?’
Analysts give credit score to Otting and his group for making large modifications previously yr. However there’s nonetheless loads of work to do, they acknowledge.
The tempo of progress hinges on whether or not the financial institution will be capable of revamp its mortgage portfolio. Turning a longtime multifamily lender right into a extra conventional industrial financial institution generally is a prolonged course of.
“The issue proper now could be with charges coming down,” mentioned Peter Winter, an analyst at D.A. Davidson. “It is accelerating paydowns within the multifamily area, and the difficulty is they do not have sufficient industrial mortgage progress to offset the paydowns, so the steadiness sheet remains to be shrinking.”
To date, the financial institution is sticking with the expectation that it’s going to return to profitability by the tip of the yr, largely as a result of “they really feel fairly assured” that later in 2024 “they will see industrial mortgage progress originations outpace payoffs and get the steadiness sheet rising,” Winter mentioned.
“On paper, every part appears good from a credit score perspective, however I believe you want a few quarters to indicate it,” Winter mentioned. “The inventory nonetheless trades at 70% tangible e book worth, so I do not assume everyone is on board from a credit score danger standpoint.”
12 months to this point, the inventory worth is up 25%. However it’s nonetheless far under the place it was buying and selling in mid-2023.
Given how OneWest was ultimately bought, questions have arisen about whether or not Flagstar is in the end being positioned to be acquired. At an business convention final month, Otting mentioned the financial institution would “be seen as a really engaging franchise” after the credit score points are resolved, commercial-and-industrial lending is rising and the corporate begins recording earnings once more.
Otting, through the interview, mentioned a sale “just isn’t the tip objective.” The corporate is investing $30 million to $40 million this yr on anti-money-laundering software program and buyer privateness, plus one other $70 million to $80 million on expertise. “You do not try this until you could have a long-term horizon,” he mentioned.
As to the view that Flagstar nonetheless must execute, Otting does not argue in any other case. He mentioned he expects to be concerned for about 5 years — three as CEO and one other two as chairman.
“We solved capital. We solved liquidity. We solved credit score,” he mentioned. “And I believe the following constructing block will likely be, can this group now develop the financial institution and change into worthwhile?”
Learn extra: Industrial actual property faces new challenges after LA fires
